| Platinum | Mama Stortini's Restaurant & Bar |
| Gold | Verrazano's Italian Restaurant |
| Silver | Black Angus Steakhouse |
| Bronze | Chopped Leaf |
| Top Pick | Azteca Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Billy McHale's |
| Top Pick | Biscuits Cafe |
| Top Pick | Ivar's Seafood Bar |
| Top Pick | Jasmine Mongolian Grill |
| Top Pick | Jps |